Best Seafood in North Naples, FL

The Ultimate Lobster Roll That'll Make You Swoon

Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Maine Roll

Fresh maine lobster, mayo

Add Item

New England Roll

Fresh maine lobster mayo, mixed greens & lemon

Add Item

Connecticut Roll

Fresh maine lobster melted butter, served warm

Add Item

The LBI Roll

Fresh maine lobster roll avocado, mayo & tomato

Add Item

Lobster Salad

Add Item

Our Unique Flavor

Savor Cold Waters Best

Fresh Maine Lobster Delivered Daily

All Fresh-Shelled Lobster Meat

All Rolls Touched with Butter

Everything Made to Order

Welcome to Mystic Lobster Rolls

Cozy and friendly spot in Naples, Florida, known for our award-winning lobster 🦞 roll in town — 2022, 2023, and 2024. Stop by for a family meal, grab something to go, or order in — we make it easy and enjoyable. There's something on the menu for everyone, from the classics to creative takes. We're here to serve you in a relaxed setting that feels just right.

A Menu for Everyone in the Family

Our menu has been designed to offer something for everyone in the family. Kids will love our fresh Maine lobster rolls, while adults can enjoy a variety of other options like our fresh salads or lobster tacos. It’s a great spot for a family outing, a quick lunch, or a casual dinner. All fresh-shelled lobster meat! Everything made to order! All rolls touched with butter. Whatever the occasion, you’ll feel right at home at Mystic Lobster Rolls.

Fast and Simple Ordering

Ordering is quick and simple! Just pick up the phone or use our easy online ordering system, and your meal will be ready before you know it. No need to wait in long lines – your food can be delivered directly to your home, or you can swing by and pick it up. We know your time is valuable, so we’ve made it easy for you to get your favorite fresh Maine lobster rolls whenever you want.

Order Now

Savor the Experience, Frame by Frame

Here’s a sneak peek of the items our customers can’t stop talking about

Taste the Award-Winning Difference! 🏆

Our lobster rolls have earned prestigious awards in 2022, 2023, and 2024. With a focus on quality and taste, we’re proud to serve the best rolls in Naples. Come enjoy an award-winning meal today!

Event Catering Made Easy! Let Us Serve You

Looking to elevate your next event? We offer catering services with over 30,000 fresh Maine lobster rolls served to happy guests. Our team can stay during your event to serve the food, ensuring everything runs smoothly. Let us take care of the food, so you can focus on enjoying the moment!

Book Your Event With Us!

Secure Your Table for a Delicious Meal!

Planning a visit? Booking a table is quick and easy. Just let us know when you’re coming, and we’ll have everything ready for you. Perfect for a casual meal, small group, or special gathering.

Reserve Your Spot Now!

Happy Hour at Mystic Lobster Rolls

Join us for Happy Hour at Mystic Lobster Rolls, where you can enjoy great deals on drinks and appetizers. It's the perfect time to unwind with family and friends in our casual atmosphere. Come by and enjoy refreshing drinks and tasty bites at unbeatable prices! Happy Hour is available every day from 3–5 pm, including Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday. Don’t miss out on these fantastic deals!

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

The best lobster roll I've had in my entire life, and I've had a lot. Huge portions and delicious flavor. Service exceptional. We will be back!!!

Alexandra S.

Stopped in for dinner tonight. My husband and I enjoyed a bowl of Clam Chowder, Classic New England Roll and a Classic Connecticut Roll. Fresh and delicious! Excellent service. Attentive and friendly.